Homemade sweets by Emma · Sarasota, FL

Brown butter cookies made in small batches

The Brown Butter Farmhouse logo: a farmhouse porch with a tray of cookies, a cinnamon roll and farm fresh eggs

How it works

Order ahead, pick up fresh

  1. 1

    Pre-order

    Pre-orders open Sunday at 1 pm and close Wednesday at midnight. Fill out the form below with the cookies you want. Batches are small, so earlier is better.

  2. 2

    I confirm by text

    I’ll text you back with your total, a pickup window and how to pay. Payment is due before pickup or delivery.

  3. 3

    Friday pickup or delivery

    Cookies are baked for Friday. Grab your box from the porch. If you live in Myakka Valley Ranches, I’ll drop it off for free.

Pickup & delivery

Pickup is in Myakka Valley Ranches, Sarasota. Delivery is free for neighbors inside Myakka Valley Ranches.

Thank you

for supporting my small business! Every cookie is mixed, scooped and baked by me in my own kitchen.

— Emma

Pre-order

Reserve your cookies

Pre-orders run Sunday at 1 pm through Wednesday at midnight, for pickup or delivery on Friday. I’ll text you to confirm your total, pickup time and payment instructions. Payment is due before pickup or delivery. Nothing is charged on this site.

Ordering for Friday

How many of each?

Boxes of 6 for $20 and 12 for $40 are applied automatically (gluten-free and cream pie not included).

Estimated total: $0.00

Your order isn’t confirmed until I text you back.

Questions

Good to know

What is brown butter?

Butter cooked slowly until the milk solids toast and turn golden. It tastes nutty, a little like toffee, and it’s the base of every cookie on the menu.

When can I order?

Pre-orders open Sunday at 1 pm, when the new menu goes up, and close Wednesday at midnight. Everything is baked for Friday pickup or delivery. Batches are small and they sell out, so earlier in the week is better.

How do I pay?

Payment instructions come in my confirmation text, along with your total. Payment is due before pickup or delivery.

Is the gluten-free cookie safe for celiac?

No. It’s made with gluten-free flour, but I bake in a home kitchen that also uses regular flour, so I can’t promise zero cross-contact. I don’t recommend it for anyone with celiac disease.

Does the menu change?

Yes. The menu rotates, so check back each week.

Can I change or cancel?

Let me know at least 24 hours before your pickup day. After that the dough is usually already made.

Where do I pick up?

Myakka Valley Ranches in Sarasota. I’ll send the exact address and a pickup window when I confirm.

Do you do events?

Yes! Parties, showers, office treats and other events. Email me at brownbutterfarmhouse@gmail.com with the date and how many cookies you need.

Do you deliver?

Yes, free, inside Myakka Valley Ranches only. Everyone else picks up from my porch in the neighborhood.

Reviews

Kind words

Your rating

Reviews usually show up here within a few minutes.

Hungry yet?

This week’s batches are small. Get your order in early.

Pre-order cookies

Planning a party or event? I do those too. Email brownbutterfarmhouse@gmail.com.

Pre-order cookies →